When a healthcare provider makes a mistake, the consequences can be devastating. But not every medical error is legally considered malpractice. In Louisiana, the distinction between negligence and medical malpractice can affect your ability to file a claim, what you need to prove, and how much compensation you may receive. Understanding this difference is crucial if you or a loved one has suffered harm due to a healthcare provider’s actions.

What Is Considered Negligence in Louisiana?

Negligence refers to a general failure to exercise reasonable care. In the context of healthcare, this could mean a provider made a mistake that another reasonable provider might have avoided, even if they weren’t acting with intentional harm or gross incompetence. It can stem from a broad range of actions or omissions, often related to inattentiveness, miscommunication, or failure to follow established procedures.

Request a FREE Case Review

What Is Medical Malpractice?

Medical malpractice is a specific type of negligence committed by licensed healthcare professionals. It goes beyond mere error—malpractice involves a violation of the professional standard of care that another provider in the same field and circumstances would have upheld, resulting in injury or harm to the patient.

Key Elements to Prove in Medical Malpractice Claims:

To establish a malpractice claim in Louisiana, the plaintiff must prove:

• A provider–patient relationship existed.
• The provider owed a duty to meet a recognized standard of care within their medical specialty.
• There was a breach of that standard.
• The breach directly caused injury or worsened a medical condition.
• The patient suffered measurable damages as a result.

Unlike general negligence claims, expert testimony is almost always required in malpractice cases. Courts rely on licensed medical professionals to explain what the standard of care was and how the defendant’s actions fell short.

Differences Between Negligence and Malpractice Cases in Louisiana

Louisiana law treats medical negligence and medical malpractice differently—not just in theory, but in how each type of claim must be handled. If you’re pursuing legal action after a medical injury, understanding these distinctions is critical.

1. Scope of Liability

One of the most important legal differences lies in who can be held accountable:

• Medical malpractice claims can only be brought against qualified healthcare providers as defined under Louisiana’s Medical Malpractice Act. This includes doctors, surgeons, nurses, dentists, and certain healthcare facilities that have registered with the state’s Patient Compensation Fund.
• General negligence claims are broader. They may involve situations like hospital administrative errors, inadequate facility maintenance, or actions by unlicensed staff where the professional standard of care doesn’t apply.

For example, if a hospital’s IT system fails to deliver lab results due to a software error, causing delayed treatment, this may be categorized as general negligence—not malpractice.

2. Statute of Limitations

Louisiana has one of the strictest deadlines in the country for filing malpractice claims:

• A medical malpractice lawsuit must be filed within one year from the date the injury was discovered or should have reasonably been discovered.
• No more than three years from the date of injury applies, even if the harm wasn't immediately known.
• General negligence claims typically follow similar timelines, but without the same procedural hurdles—giving plaintiffs slightly more flexibility in some instances.

3. Medical Review Panel Requirement

Before a malpractice case can move forward in court, Louisiana law requires it to be reviewed by a medical review panel. This is a unique pre-litigation step where:

• A panel of three licensed healthcare professionals evaluates the evidence.
• The panel determines whether the standard of care was breached.
• Their findings are not binding, but they carry weight in court.

This step does not apply to general negligence claims, which can proceed directly to litigation.

4. Damage Caps

In malpractice cases, compensation is limited by law:

• Non-economic and economic damages are capped at $500,000, excluding future medical care and related costs.
• The cap does not apply to negligence claims outside the scope of Louisiana’s malpractice statute.

While the terms are often used interchangeably, negligence and medical malpractice are not the same under Louisiana law. Failing to correctly identify and file the right type of claim can result in lost compensation, case dismissal, or the inability to pursue justice at all. If you suspect either, don’t leave your health—or your future—to chance. Contact an experienced Louisiana medical malpractice attorney to protect your rights and pursue the compensation you deserve.